On December 21, 2023, the Swiss Federal Council and HM Treasury in the UK announced the signing of an agreement on mutual recognition in specific areas of financial services between Switzerland and the UK, referred to as the Berne Financial Services Agreement (the Agreement). The conclusion of this groundbreaking Agreement is the culmination of more than two years of negotiations following the signing of a Joint Statement on June 30, 2020 aiming at enhancing cooperation in financial services between Switzerland and the UK.
The key objective of the Agreement is to introduce mutual recognition in order to facilitate the provision of financial services (including insurance services) on a cross-border basis between the two countries, which face regulatory and commercial challenges regarding access to the EU market in the absence of passporting.
Key features of the Agreement
The Agreement generally provides for a mutual recognition of equivalence in the sectors of asset management, banking, investment services, financial market infrastructures, OTC derivatives and insurance for wholesale and sophisticated clients, such as professional and institutional clients.
Asset management services
The Agreement confirms the existing mutual access for marketing, including advertising and offering collective investment schemes to per se professional clients, institutional clients/eligible counterparties, and elective professional clients. The ability of UK and Swiss financial services firms to delegate portfolio and risk management activities to financial service providers of both jurisdictions is also confirmed by the Agreement.
Banking and investment services
For banking and investment services, the Agreement allows Swiss financial service providers to provide financial services, in particular portfolio management and investment advice, to per se professional clients, eligible counterparties as well as high net worth individuals with assets in excess of £2m ($2.54m) either on a cross-border basis or as part of a temporary local operation (without prejudice to UK visa and other entry requirements). This is slightly wider than the existing regime, including the “overseas persons exclusion”, that many non-UK firms currently rely on to provide investment services to UK-based clients without needing UK regulatory permissions. Under these circumstances, the Swiss financial service providers can continue to provide their services under Swiss law.
For UK financial service providers, which already benefit from a rather liberal regime for cross-border activities in Switzerland, in particular when targeting per se professional clients and eligible counterparties, the Agreement adds additional flexibility for client advisers acting on behalf of UK investment services firms. Under the Agreement, such advisers will no longer need to individually register with Swiss registration bodies to serve certain high-net-worth clients. Instead, their firm can give confirmation on their behalf that they meet the prerequisites for giving business or investment advice to Swiss clients. This will do away with the need to sit examinations and provide documentation relevant to the registration process.
Note that not all high-net-worth clients as defined under the Swiss Financial Services Act (FinSA) are covered by the Agreement, and UK financial service providers that are exempt from the registration requirement under the Agreement must still ensure that the following requirements prescribed by FinSA are met:
- their client advisers must have sufficient knowledge of the rules of conduct set out in FinSA and possess the necessary expertise required to perform their activities;
- they must have taken out professional indemnity insurance coverage or arranged for equivalent collateral in accordance with FinSA;
- they have to be affiliated with a Swiss ombudsman where required under FinSA.
Further, temporary presence in Switzerland of UK client advisers is possible (without prejudice to the respective visa and other entry requirements of Switzerland).
Financial market infrastructures and OTC derivatives
For central counterparties (CCPs), the Agreement provides for a regulatory recognition by both Switzerland and the UK. This will ensure that Swiss and UK CCPs can provide their services with greater certainty. The Agreement also includes a commitment to firm up current access to trading venues (for example stock exchanges and multilateral trading facilities).
For non-centrally cleared OTC derivatives, Swiss and UK counterparties will be free to rely on either recognized Swiss or UK risk mitigation rules (subject to UK standards and supervision of initial margin models and variation margin on physically settled FX swaps and forwards applicable to UK counterparties in accordance with UK domestic law).
Switzerland and the UK have already agreed by a side letter of December 21, 2023 to explore further cooperation in other areas including benchmarks, credit rating agencies, trade repositories, recognition of reporting and clearing obligations for OTC derivatives as well as the application of OTC derivatives intragroup exemptions for domestic firms.
Insurance services
The Agreement enables Swiss insurance undertakings to provide cross-border insurance services to large UK corporate clients. Reciprocally, the Agreement offers the same to UK insurance undertakings in Switzerland, securing access to many wholesale lines of business that go beyond what Switzerland has offered to any other trading partner to date.
The recognition concerns certain lines of non-life insurance, including liability insurance in specific and selected lines of business for professional policyholders. Provision of life, accident and health insurance, liability insurance for non-covered lines of business, monopoly insurance of any kind or business interruption insurance are not in scope and do not benefit from mutual recognition.
Based on the Agreement, non-tied insurance intermediaries in the UK will also be relieved from the new Swiss localisation requirement, which entered into force on January 1, 2024. This gives them an advantage over their competitors from all other jurisdictions, which have to establish a local presence in Switzerland.
A separate side letter dated December 21, 2023 regarding auxiliary insurance services, such as such as consultancy, actuarial, risk assessment and claim settlement services, confirms a mutual understanding that the Agreement extends to the supply of certain auxiliary insurance services to Switzerland.
What happens next
In many respects both the UK and Switzerland have had fairly liberal regimes when it comes to permitting overseas firms to carry on financial services activity with UK clients and counterparties in the UK and Switzerland, respectively, without needing a local licence. The Agreement takes this a step further. Generally, the mutual recognition set forth in the Agreement should significantly reduce the remaining regulatory barriers for Swiss and UK financial services providers and, hopefully, boost the international competitiveness of both financial centres.
Swiss industry representative bodies, such as the Swiss Bankers Association and the Asset Management Association Switzerland, but also market participants such as SIX Swiss Exchange have already welcomed the signing of the Agreement.
HM Treasury in the UK describes the Agreement as establishing “a new global best practice for regulatory and supervisory cooperation”, while UK industry representative bodies, such as TheCityUK, have welcomed the Agreement.
Following the signing of the Agreement, the Swiss Federal Council will prepare its dispatch and submit the same to the Swiss Parliament later this year. The UK Government will likewise seek to implement and ratify the agreement in due course in line with UK parliamentary processes. The Agreement requires approval by the parliaments of both countries before entering into force.
Dr Vaïk Müller is a partner and co-head of Banking and Finance CMS Geneva. Ash Saluja is a Financial Services Partner in CMS London.
A version of this article was first published by Reuters Regulatory Intelligence.